An Advertiser’s Handbook to Maximize ROI Past Amazon Prime Day

Amazon Prime Day has come and gone once more.

Adore it or hate it, you’ll be able to’t ignore it—particularly if you happen to’re an advertiser.

Final yr, sellers spent 14% of their Prime Day revenues on Amazon adverts, but many noticed their revenue margins skinny. This begs the query: how can advertisers maximize their advert spend returns in Amazon’s market monopoly?

To uncover insights, we interviewed Regina Ye, CEO and co-founder of Topsort, an AI-first advert infrastructure platform constructed for the post-cookie world. Regina is a serial entrepreneur, software program engineer, and former e-commerce vendor who is aware of firsthand the challenges of retail and performance-based advertising and marketing. 

On this interview, we discover the dynamics of Amazon Prime Day, uncover promoting methods, hear contrarian views, and dive into the way forward for advert measurement.

That is a part of G2’s Trade Insights sequence. For extra content material like this, subscribe to G2 Tea, a e-newsletter with SaaS-y information and leisure.

Kamaljeet Kalsi: Why do you suppose Amazon Prime Day is such a worthwhile occasion for Amazon?

Regina Ye: Amazon was one of many first retailers within the US to launch a giant occasion like Prime Day, giving them a first-mover benefit.

The size of Amazon Prime Day in the present day is big. As an illustration, in 2023, it was the largest occasion in Amazon’s historical past, with almost $13 billion in gross sales over simply two days. They bought roughly 375 million merchandise throughout Prime Day 2023. The market protection can be spectacular—about 45% of US adults shopped throughout Prime Day final yr. 

The exclusivity of offers for Prime members and the sheer quantity of visitors create important momentum for distributors on Amazon, making it a extremely anticipated and worthwhile occasion.

What’s the issue with Amazon Prime Day for advertisers? Are they seeing an ROI from taking part?

Most advertisers view Amazon Prime Day as a part of a long-term technique to construct their presence on Amazon, moderately than an finish aim. The competitors is fierce as a result of everybody needs consideration on Prime Day. 

Shoppers have change into savvy—they keep in-app lists of things and know precisely after they wish to buy. Distributors solely have a matter of seconds to seize their consideration. This creates stress to supply important reductions, which might eat into margins. Attributable to excessive demand, the price of adverts additionally will increase.

 Nevertheless, most manufacturers see constructive outcomes if they’ve a well-executed technique for the occasion.

What’s one golden rule manufacturers and advertisers should bear in mind throughout high-tension occasions like Amazon Prime Day?

An enormous a part of it’s the preparation within the lead-up to the occasion, which is often two weeks to a month forward.

Guaranteeing inventories are in place, budgets are set, and campaigns are prepared is essential. Capturing momentum after the occasion is equally necessary. 

With out correct preparation, it looks like every other day. Nevertheless, with a stable plan each earlier than and after, manufacturers can have a extremely profitable Prime Day.

Moreover, this ties into information assortment. It’s not nearly advertising and marketing within the current however capturing the appropriate information factors to tell future methods. By correlating this information, manufacturers can improve their strategy for upcoming occasions like the vacation season, making certain a extra complete and efficient technique.

Do you suppose advertisers ought to discover placing their advert spend into different marketplaces, as an alternative of feeling pressured to take part in Amazon Prime Day?

Completely.

There are important advantages to spreading advert spend throughout totally different retailers and marketplaces and testing numerous methods. Amazon is dominant and has a superb membership system, however different, extra vertical-focused retailers and marketplaces could be higher suited to particular product classes.

It all the time pays to strive totally different retailers and see which of them work finest for specific merchandise. By diversifying, manufacturers can discover the best platforms that resonate most with their target market and product sort.

Is it smarter to make use of Prime Day for viewers progress after which diversify to different platforms for launches or reselling?

Amazon affords wonderful sponsored listings and promoting choices, which work significantly properly on Prime Day for distributors centered on conversions and gross sales. If the technique is to drive product gross sales, put together properly upfront, and execute efficient adverts on Prime Day. There will probably be important visitors, conversions, and purchases.

Nevertheless, some manufacturers in the present day could choose to construct their very own direct-to-consumer (DTC) channels and never be confined to a single retailer. 

For these manufacturers, diversifying throughout numerous retail channels is smart to construct broader protection and improve model consciousness. Through the use of totally different marketplaces, manufacturers can attain new audiences and launch new merchandise extra successfully.

In case you don’t wish to put all of your promoting eggs into the Amazon Prime Day basket, which platforms or methods do you suppose are extra worthwhile for buying new audiences?

It is a very nuanced query and is dependent upon the model’s technique. If a model is targeted on constructing its personal model consciousness and a DTC mannequin, having its personal web site and managing a complete DTC channel affords many long-term advantages. The model is just not on the mercy of 1 platform.

Lately, competitors for Amazon has elevated considerably.

Many retailers are adopting comparable methods, changing into extra digital with well-optimized web sites and complete advert choices. Platforms like Finest Purchase, Goal, and Walmart all have their very own advert networks and supply alternatives for diversification.

These platforms enable manufacturers to impression sell-through charges and total gross sales. Diversifying by getting into a number of retail channels can show useful, as these platforms additionally cope with excessive volumes and have loyal buyer bases.

How can a market make the promoting expertise worthwhile for each {the marketplace} and advertisers? Is that even doable?

It all the time comes all the way down to having a great product with an optimized itemizing.

Robust fundamentals are key—first rate conversion and click-through charges make it safer to speculate extra in promoting. The promoting instruments ought to be simple to make use of and measure, with clear and clear reporting.

One in every of my favourite issues about Amazon’s adverts is the convenience of understanding the outcomes, which additionally makes reporting simpler. These instruments assist create a shrewd promoting technique, permitting fast changes based mostly on suggestions and making certain profitability. So, sure, it’s nonetheless doable to make the promoting expertise worthwhile.

On the flip facet, whereas Amazon is a strong promoting channel, its complicated processes can intimidate new distributors or SMB sellers. From Colleen Aubrey’s keynote at Shoptalk 2024, I discovered that one remorse Amazon’s authentic advert group had was their heavy reliance on key phrases. This strategy requires the usage of each unfavorable and constructive key phrases that provides pointless guesswork and handbook tweaking. An intuitive, plug-and-play strategy might yield higher outcomes. This displays how the platform’s design is from a unique period.

What do you suppose marketplaces like Walmart, Finest Purchase, Goal, or Alibaba are doing higher than what Amazon is doing? Do you suppose Amazon will keep its main place?

We will’t deny that Amazon continues to be the business chief with the depth and breadth of options which are onerous to beat.

They began forward of everybody else, launching their undertaking again in 2004. Through the years, they’ve gained in depth data within the promoting house. Nevertheless, Amazon’s market dynamics are very aggressive, with many sellers vying for consideration.

Newer gamers can appeal to sellers by presenting a much less aggressive surroundings. In the long term, for Finest Purchase, Goal, or Walmart to compete successfully with Amazon, particularly in promoting—which is Amazon’s major revenue driver—they want refined expertise.

To retain its main place, Amazon should excel in areas like auctions, relevance, machine studying, and reporting. Whereas launching new choices can generate preliminary pleasure, scaling these promoting techniques successfully is the true problem these platforms face.

They should improve their technological capabilities to remain aggressive.

What would you say to marketplaces who’re skeptical about including an promoting or retail media platform into their providing? Ought to they be anxious it might negatively have an effect on the procuring expertise?

I perceive the skepticism, as it is a rising market with a number of hype and aggressive numbers, making it a loud house. It turns into difficult to tell apart between real expertise and copycats.

Nevertheless, it is essential to set issues proper from the outset, specializing in relevance. 

Do not create a parallel search engine; guarantee adverts do not work in opposition to search capabilities. Whereas adverts could herald income, in the event that they detract from the general expertise, it might result in losses elsewhere and never contribute to total progress.

We have heard tales of shops stopping their advert packages resulting from cannibalization, however that is avoidable with correct measurement, relevance, and proposals.

As an illustration, keep away from irrelevant adverts like automotive insurance coverage adverts when clients seek for footwear. Strong analytics are additionally important. With no suggestions loop to grasp ROI, it turns into troublesome to speculate extra.

Most significantly, it is a golden age for retail media, presenting an thrilling alternative. Many gamers are centered on making it simpler to try to experiment with new applied sciences. These efforts open new avenues for retailers to compete with giants like Amazon.

How can manufacturers guarantee their search engine marketing and promoting efforts are usually not canceling one another out?

It is important to view the general progress of {the marketplace} holistically moderately than seeing adverts and non-ads as separate entities.

When they’re handled as competing tasks, they find yourself preventing for a similar assets, which might be counterproductive. Internally, our group at Topsort has invested substantial effort and time to inject this cohesive strategy as an integral a part of our product technique.

Typically, trade-offs are essential to protect the general well being and progress of {the marketplace}. As an illustration, if an advert is of poor high quality however is paid for, it could be higher to not present it, as this determination can profit {the marketplace}’s total income in the long term.

3 tricks to make search engine marketing and promoting work collectively

• Combine search engine marketing and promoting groups to make sure cohesive methods
• Use information analytics to measure the impression of each search engine marketing and adverts on total progress
• Prioritize person expertise in each search engine marketing and promoting efforts

How can retailers leverage first-party information for advert personalization to realize a aggressive edge within the cookieless future?

There are a number of choices for leveraging first-party information.

Some market gamers use buyer information platforms (CDPs) or keep detailed electronic mail lists to maintain observe of their core clients and audiences. One other suggestion is to make use of a stable cleanroom product if refined viewers information is out there. This allows collaboration and information sharing throughout the partnership ecosystem, permitting for more practical information utilization.

Nevertheless, it is also price contemplating a contrarian view: retail media continues to be in its early levels, and the facility of search on retailers is substantial. 

When shoppers are on a platform like Sephora looking for sunscreen, the patron intent is already very excessive. In such circumstances, personalization is not all the time crucial for good marketing campaign outcomes—it may be seen extra as a secondary optimization moderately than a necessity to get began.

How can advertisers harness the facility of evaluations to strengthen their promoting technique?

Opinions are among the many high components shoppers contemplate earlier than shopping for something, typically ranked within the high three. On the product element web page (PDP), evaluations are regularly probably the most clicked and the highest supply of conversions. 

Clients closely depend on evaluations when collections, making them a vital component of the buying determination. Opinions additionally present a superb alternative to construct a way of group. 

Many manufacturers are already doing this by utilizing evaluations as a cornerstone of their shopper content material technique and utilizing user-generated content material (UGC). This strategy tends to be way more highly effective than something a marketer might say about their very own merchandise.

Do publishers profit when retailers combine product listings and commercials into their content material to remain top-of-mind with shoppers?

At the moment, these two worlds are considerably disjointed.

It will be a lot better in the event that they have been linked. It may be difficult for retailers or advertisers to grasp how a lot gross sales exercise outcomes from articles in publications just like the New York Instances or Vogue. 

The attribution is commonly damaged.

At the moment, that is often achieved with cookies or privacy-focused monitoring approaches. We’re engaged on cleanroom expertise that would assist bridge this hole, as are others out there. Combining these items to get a great view of the client journey can be very attention-grabbing. 

Proper now, these capabilities are largely thought of separate and are usually owned by separate groups inside corporations, akin to advertising and marketing and vendor relationship groups.

How can the promoting methods used for Amazon Prime Day be tailored for gross sales at Walmart, Goal, and Finest Purchase?

Many of those retailers have already adopted comparable practices by internet hosting their very own buyer acquisition occasions. These occasions are efficient for constructing visitors and momentum. Nevertheless, the problem for these retailers is to supply a novel worth proposition that distinguishes them from Amazon and different opponents. 

It is not nearly replicating Amazon’s techniques but additionally about understanding what units a model aside. Moreover, having sturdy reporting is essential to justify the ROI for sellers and advertisers. This contains making certain the accuracy of efficiency metrics and utilizing insights to fine-tune methods.

How can entrepreneurs report higher ROI?

To report higher ROI, it is important to make sure there are APIs for reporting that may present largely real-time information suggestions. This enables visibility into impressions, clicks, and purchases as they occur. Moreover, most manufacturers at a sure scale ought to have their very own information lake and reporting instruments to centralize all this data. 

One problem we frequently hear from manufacturers investing in a number of channels is the inconsistency in how totally different platforms measure impressions, clicks, and purchases. This results in confusion about whether or not manufacturers are evaluating apples to apples. Having a unified measurement system is essential for constructing belief in reporting.

Ideas for higher ROI reporting 

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. In molestie dolor lacinia sem ultrices fringilla. Donec neque ipsum, tincidunt non tristique sed, imperdiet et nisi.

• Use APIs to get real-time suggestions on impressions, clicks, and purchases
• Preserve an information lake and reporting instruments to maintain all experiences in a single place
• Guarantee constant measurement throughout totally different platforms
• Use a unified system to measure ROI throughout all channels for correct comparisons

How do you foresee the problem of inconsistent information reporting throughout totally different platforms being solved within the close to future?

There are a number of gamers attempting to unravel this subject. 

Firms like Skai and Pacvue, amongst others, have developed instruments to higher perceive and mix metrics from totally different platforms. Nevertheless, the problem turns into extra pronounced down-market with totally different retailers, particularly these on a smaller scale.

One resolution is having a common catalog to standardize stock-keeping models (SKUs) throughout marketplaces, much like how Amazon has efficiently carried out its AWS Certificates Supervisor (ACM) system. Our product additionally goals to deal with these challenges by offering a unified measurement strategy for retail media networks, making it simpler to standardize reporting. 

The difficulty of inconsistent information reporting is a crucial problem given the explosion of retail media networks. With no standardized system, it turns into extraordinarily troublesome to check and perceive your entire panorama precisely.

How do you see the position of expertise evolving within the advertising and marketing and promoting house, particularly when it comes to reworking from an artwork to a science?

I consider this house is present process a big transformation—from what was as soon as thought of the Wild West, the place everybody was simply attempting issues out, to a extra scientific strategy centered on scalability and measurement. 

During the last 6 to 7 years, we have noticed main gamers initiating this shift. Now, over half of the highest 10 U.S. retail media networks are considering upgrading from legacy platforms and deciding whether or not to construct in-house options or go for additional customization.

These corporations at the moment are getting into the two.0 or 3.0 section, with a future-first deal with methods to remain forward of the curve. Expertise performs a vital position on this evolution, making advertising and marketing and promoting extra data-driven and scalable.

What product optimization ideas can increase promoting conversions and model consciousness?

It is dependent upon the precise merchandise manufacturers are pushing. 

For brand new product launches, occasions like Prime Day are wonderful for constructing credibility with a excessive quantity of evaluations and providing incentives for evaluations. UGC is extraordinarily efficient in describing merchandise authentically.

Amazon affords video adverts, and lots of different retailers and marketplaces now supply this format as properly. Video adverts are significantly helpful for brand new and area of interest merchandise requiring detailed explanations or demonstrations, serving to to construct model consciousness.

Moreover, it is important to stability long-term model consciousness with promoting conversions.

After main occasions like Prime Day, keep visibility to make sure folks bear in mind the model. Small techniques like organising a robust on-line presence, together with memorable objects within the transport, akin to samples or reward playing cards, could make a big impression. Amazon is sort of versatile relating to what manufacturers can embrace within the product packaging, permitting them to reinforce the client expertise and create a viral loop.

From a contrarian perspective, what optimization ideas are you able to supply for platforms apart from Amazon?

Amazon might be considerably inflexible and limiting except manufacturers make investments extra in customized branding and enterprise belongings. Some platforms are extra user-friendly for producing content material. It is typically more practical to make use of Amazon primarily for conversions whereas constructing and proudly owning model consciousness on different platforms.

Distribute high-quality content material throughout numerous channels, and as soon as it is evident what’s working, leverage Amazon adverts to drive publicity. Constantly experiment with various kinds of content material to see what resonates most with the viewers.

Are you able to construct a number of momentum on Amazon and efficiently comply with the identical on different platforms to decrease the price of acquisition?

It is a bit tough. Amazon is a really robust platform with a well-established model. As a vendor attempting to construct their model on Amazon, they both have an exterior model presence and use Amazon for gross sales or wrestle to construct model recognition solely on Amazon. 

Many sellers discover success in driving purchases and conversions on Amazon however typically face challenges replicating that success elsewhere. 

If Amazon modifications its guidelines or insurance policies, it may be troublesome to take care of momentum on different platforms. Subsequently, it is more practical to construct the model independently and use Amazon primarily as a distribution and conversion channel.

In case you loved this insightful dialog, subscribe to the G2 Tea e-newsletter for the most recent tech and advertising and marketing thought management.

---

Comply with Regina Ye on LinkedIn and study extra about the way forward for retail media and promoting.

Edited by Sinchana Mistry